Question about the Sierra High Route vs just doing the JMT again
Three years ago I hiked the JMT and loved it, but last month I did a 5 day stretch of the Sierra High Route near Dusy Basin and it kicked my ass in a way the JMT never did. Now I'm arguing with my hiking buddy about which one to plan for next summer. My take is the SHR is worth the extra route finding and talus hopping because you get the basins to yourself, but he says why suffer when the JMT has a real trail and reliable water. For those who have done both, which one would you put a newer backpacker on, and am I crazy for thinking the crowds on the JMT are reason enough to switch?