Wrote off peat pots as a gimmick for years until a side-by-side in my garage changed my mind
For years I started my tomato seeds in the cheap plastic six-packs from the hardware store on Delmar, mostly because my dad did it that way and it worked fine. Last March I set up a row of peat pots next to the plastic ones, same soil, same south window, same watering schedule. Eight weeks later the peat pot seedlings had roots poking through the sides and barely any transplant shock, while half my plastic ones sulked for two weeks after going in the ground. Turned out the roots just kept circling in the plastic cells and never got going. Now I'm wondering if the coir ones are worth the extra couple bucks, or if anyone has tried the paper pot maker thing instead.