Everyone says to start icons on a 24px grid, but I got my best set going from 20px down instead
I keep seeing folks in here say you have to lock your icon grid to 24px before you draw anything, and I just don't buy it after the set I finished two weeks ago. I was doing a little weather widget for my own site and started on a 24px grid like usual, but the raindrops and snowflakes kept turning into mush once I snapped the curves to whole pixels. So I flipped it and drew everything at 20px first where the shapes stayed clean, then scaled the whole file to 24. Two of the icons needed a tiny nudge on the stroke after that, but the set finally looked right and I stopped fighting the grid. My point is the grid should follow the shape, not the other way around, and starting smaller gave me more room to make the small details read. If you've built a set this way, how did you handle the odd sizes, or do you just keep everything on the standard grid no matter what?
Take the shape first idea even further and pick your grid per icon family, not per set. If your weather icons live at 20px, build the whole weather family at 20 and only step up to 24 when you need to mix them into a UI that's already on 24. The odd sizes stop being a problem once you keep a little master file per size and just nudge the strokes there instead of redrawing. Ngl the two icons that needed a stroke tweak after scaling are the real tell, that's normal and way less work than redrawing mush curves. Curious how you handled the pixel fit on rotated stuff like the snowflake, that's where my 20px trick always falls apart.