Serious question, did the cinnamon trick actually save my seedlings or did I just get lucky?
Fungus gnats took over my 6 seed trays on the kitchen windowsill here in Duluth back in March, so out of pure frustration I dusted the soil with cinnamon from the spice rack and the little bugs vanished in about 4 days, but now I can't tell if it was the cinnamon or just drying things out, so has anyone actually tested this or are we all just repeating a garden forum rumor?
Six trays on a kitchen windowsill in Duluth in March is a lot of soil surface to keep wet, so drying things out was probably doing more work than you think. Fungus gnat larvae need damp soil to live, and cinnamon does have some real antifungal stuff in it, so both things were likely helping at once. The catch is that the drying part is what actually breaks their life cycle, and if you kept watering the same way after the cinnamon, they'd probably come right back. I've been down this road with gnats and the thing that finally worked was bottom watering and letting the top inch dry out between rounds. So my guess is you got a little of both, but the dry soil did the heavy lifting. Cinnamon is cheap and smells nice, so no harm keeping it in the routine.