Loading…
11
I went into our book club hating the main character and came out defending her
Honestly, last month we read 'The Vanishing Half' and I spent the whole book being so mad at Stella for passing as white. I thought it was a selfish choice, plain and simple. But during our meeting, my friend Lisa, who's a social worker, pointed out a line I'd totally missed. She read it out loud: 'The better her life got, the more she missed the people she'd left.' Lisa said it wasn't about shame, but about the awful price of safety in 1960s Louisiana. She talked about how fear can make people do things that look like betrayal from the outside. That one conversation, hearing her break it down with real history, flipped my whole view. I went from judging Stella to feeling a deep sadness for the impossible spot she was in. Ngl, it was a heavy night, but it's why I love this group. Has anyone else had a book club talk completely change how you saw a character's big choice?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
miles_roberts226mo ago
Stella still abandoned her whole family for a white picket fence.
6
oscarm243mo ago
Abandoned her whole family" feels a little dramatic honestly. She's an adult woman who made a tough call in a messed up situation. I mean yeah it's not a perfect choice but people act like she packed her bags and walked out on a bunch of kids. She went to get something better for herself when the system already failed her. It's not that deep, some of yall act like she committed a war crime.
1
faith_smith6mo ago
What if the book is less about judging her choice and more about showing how the system forces those choices on people?
0