T
5

Talked to an old mason about mixing sand for a repair job

He was fixing a 100 year old wall in the historic district. I asked about his mix. He said 'Kid, the sand's the thing. You got sharp sand for strength, soft sand for work. I use a 2 to 1 sharp to soft for repairs like this.' I always just grabbed whatever was cheap. Tried his ratio on a chimney rebuild last month. The mortar felt totally different. Stuck better, tooled smoother. Made me rethink every bag I've ever bought. What's your go-to sand mix for old brickwork?
2 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In
2 Comments
morgan_jenkins90
Yeah, that part about missing the fine details hits hard. It's like @evana71 said, we just grab the standard bag. I see it with tools too, everyone wants the fancy new gadget but they don't know how to use a basic hand tool right. That old guy's sand mix is a perfect little lesson. It's not about having more stuff, it's about knowing how the simple things work together. That knowledge used to pass from person to person, now it just gets lost.
5
evana71
evana7113d agoTop Commenter
Man, that's such a perfect example of how we miss the fine details now. We're trained to just grab the standard, pre-mixed bag of whatever (concrete, soil, even paint) and assume it's all the same. That old mason knew the specific ingredients matter for the specific job, not just the general category. It's like the difference between cooking with any old salt versus knowing when to use kosher salt to make things stick. That kind of hands-on knowledge is getting lost because it's easier to just buy the one-size-fits-all stuff.
2